Abdur-Raheem Green - The Many Aspects Of Shirk
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
Select a speaker
Report Ad
Who's Online?
Navigation
Newest Additions
- Yaser Birjas - Defending the Prophet (S) Against Orientalist Critique
- Halal Tube on Facebook, MySpace and Twitter!
- Abdul Bary Yahya - The Emigration to Abyssinia
- Abdal Hakim Murad - Seeing by Allah’s Light
- Abdal Hakim Murad - Sacrifice & Submission
- Zaid Shakir - Obama and American Muslims: The Way Forward
- Faraz Rabbani - Obama and American Muslims: Hope, Change, Success, and Attitude
Recent Comments
As-salaamu’alaykum wa Rahmatu Llahi wa Barakatuhu
Masha’Allah, definitely a lecture we all need to listen to, even if you ‘think’ you know enough on this topic. Please make some time to listen to it, and insha’Allah learn from it.
Wa’alaykum as-salaam
Farhana
Alhamdulillah. Excellent lecture. May Allah bless Abdur Raheem Green.
Is he a scholar? People should read books by real scholars, even if some of the things brother AR Green says are useful and basic concepts of Tawhid, we should be careful to analyse what he says and not take everything at face value.
Especially on issues where there is Ikhtilaf (difference of opinion) between scholars i.e. tawassul. There is an adab of issues where there is ikhtilaf and sadly a lot of da’ees do not confirm to this. Read about the classical scholars of Islam (Abu Hanifa, Muslim, Ahmad, Malik, Nawawi etc) and you will see their exemplery manners when there is a difference of opinion of an issue and how they respect the other point of view. Remember Allah could have made Islam a rigid deen full of black and white rules, instead it is testimony to his infinite mercy that he has allowed these differences. SubhanAllah
ameen to the dua of Nurulhuda.we as muslims sometimes need to speak the good or keep quite. when ever there is someone such as a caller to islam or a scholar speaking good and forbiding the evil, theres muslims opening there mouths trying to discredit them. i am sick of reading negative comments about other muslims all the time, we need to fear Allah and stop. if someone wants to find out about the qualifications or the teachers of a sheikh, than thats fine, they should do that privately, but to yap yap about them on line is ignorance and a sinful deed.
Umm Yahya - isn’t knowledge fard? isn’t there a massive responsibility when giving Da’wah? ARG is the 1 who is having digs at people who do certain practices, what I am saying is that there is a difference of opinion between the scholars as to the permissibility of these practices (i.e. intercession of the awliya). Therefore, ARG has no right to drop fatwa’s, he is not even a scholar. Look at the status of the Sahaba that our beloved Rasool Allah (SAW) sent to give da’wah to Yemen, Iraq etc, they were some of the most knowledgeable. We need to maintain the integrity of our deen by educating ourselves and then people like ARG would be challenged when giving 1 sided salafi arguments without acknowledging that people who follow traditional teachings and scholars differ.
Sister Umm Yahya - by the way, reform of the self (Jihad of Nafs) comes before enjoining what is good and forbidding what is evil. i.e. sort yourself out (gain knowledge etc) b4 sorting others out
Salaams
AH I agree. Painful, painful viewing, this should come with a WARNING!
This is not da’wah, this a just a blatant churning out of the Salafi agenda.
I wonder what Ijaza’s he has to transmit hadith?
Just been having a listen and am somewhat disappointed and upset at brother ARG’s thinly veiled attack on traditional Islam. Even with my miniscule knowledge (im striving, inshallah) I can spot the fatwa of shirk on people who practice Tawassul. There are traditions which support this practice and he should be aware of these and point these out(i.e. time of drought during Hazrat Umar’s (RA) reign, the baraka of Imam Bukhari’s grave, Imam Ahmed’s approval etc).
Another reason I am disappointed is that brother ARG has signed up to the Muslim Unity thing (along with others), and this “attack” hardly helps the cause.
I implore every1 to listen to the most eminent Sheikh Mohammed Al Yaqoubi’s talk entitled “Ignorance - The disease of our times”. This talk puts my earlier comments into perspective.
Please search for the talk as it is not on Halal Tube. May Allah preserve the learned Sheikh and all the true scholars of Sacred Knowledge.
Brothers and sisters we should remember about the ettiquettes of correcting our brother or sister if they do something wrong. It is how you or I would like to be told when we make a mistake. Alone, privately with confidentiality. It is a practice of real Muslim’s as well as good ethics. We also must remember that no one is perfect except angels, and to think of our own shortcoming before we speak as though we are better than others.
if anyone want to listen to shayk muhammad al yaqoubi talk entitled ignorance-the disease of our time go to http://www.muhabbat ul deen .com to listen to it
ameen to ur dua AH may allah preserve shaykh muhammad yaqubi for this ummah and elavate his rank ameen
mashallah very good talk by shaykh muhammad yaqubi i think ARG should talk to shaykh muhammad about tawassul and if he want quran and sunnah im sure shaykh muhammad can provide him with it a true scholar
May Allah bless Rasool Allah (SAW), our guiding light, the mercy to the worlds, the illuminating lamp, the shadowless noor, the 1 who has been promised the most exalted station of intercession.
May Allah accept our dua’s and pleas of intercession to Rasool Allah (SAW), Al Gawth al Azam Sheikh Abdal Qadir Gilani (RA) and all the pious Awliya and Siddiqeen.
Salam…
ARG is okay. If you want to go deeper in details, you can dig on works and fatawa by well known SUNNAH ulama’ of our time, Shaykh Albani (rahimahumullah), Shaykh Uthaymeen (rahimahumullah), ibn Baaz (rahimahumullah), Shaykh Salih Al Fawzan, etc etc.
http://www.albani.co.uk, http://www.binbaz.co.uk, http://www.binuthaymin.co.uk, http://www.fawzan.co.uk, http://www.rabee.co.uk, http://www.muqbil.co.uk, http://www.ubayd.co.uk http://www.bakkah.net, http://www.fatwaislam.com, http://www.masjiduthaymeen.com, http://www.al-athariyyah.com, http://www.sunnahpublishing.net, http://www.therighteouspath.com
http://www.fatwa-online.com, http://www.sayingsofthesalaf.net
InsyaAllah.